House Committee Votes to Hold Eric Holder in Contempt of Congress


White House invokes Executive Privilege,
refuses to release subpoenaed documents


“How can the President assert executive privilege if there was no White House involvement? How can the President exert executive privilege over documents he’s supposedly never seen? Is something very big being hidden to go to this extreme?” — Senator Chuck Grassley(R-IA), June 20, 2012


Having promised that his administration would be the “most open and transparent in history,” President Barack Obama invoked executive privilege today to lock up documents that House investigators were seeking in relation to the cover-up surrounding Operation Fast & Furious.

In response, the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee voted to hold Eric Holder in contempt of Congress, noting that he has consistently refused to release thousands upon thousands of subpoenaed documents.

Executive privilege has been used by Presidents in the past (all the way back to George Washington) as a mechanism to protect sensitive documents relating to things like the military, foreign powers, or the President’s power to pardon.

But today’s invoking of executive privilege was not aimed at protecting the country.  Rather, it appears to be nothing more than a crass attempt to cover-up lies and misstatements made by Eric Holder and others in his department.  Consider some of the following:

  • The Justice Department — in a letter dated February 4, 2011 — told Congress that the U.S. does not knowingly help smuggle guns into Mexico.  The Justice Department had to retract that letter ten months later.
  • On May 5, 2011, Attorney General Eric Holder testified before Congress that he only learned about Fast & Furious “a few weeks ago.”  Later, he had to confess that it would have been more accurate to say “a couple of months” ago — and even that statement was dubious considering that he had received memos on Fast & Furious as far back as July, 2010.
  • On June 12, 2012, Attorney General Holder defiantly told Sen. John Cornyn (R-TX) that the Bush administration knew that guns were being smuggled into Mexico as part of a program called Operation Wide Receiver.  The insinuation was that the Obama administration simply inherited a “gun walking” program that was out of control.  Today, however, Holder had to retract his earlier statement that Bush officials knew about “gun walking.”
  • Finally, there are the leaked affidavits.  As reported by John Lott today, a mole in the Justice Department gave Rep. Darrell Issa’s Oversight and Government Reform Committee a set of wiretap applications “proving that high department officials knew about the administration’s efforts to aid the gun smuggling.”  As noted by Lott, this destroyed much of Holder’s credibility since he had claimed these wiretap applications were not relevant to Fast & Furious and justified his refusal to release them.


Technically speaking, executive privilege is supposed to be employed to protect deliberations where the President was personally involved.  Hence, the invoking of the privilege seems to suggest that the President (or his top deputies) have known more about Fast & Furious than has heretofore been admitted by any Justice Department official.

It’s interesting that Eric Holder wanted to get immunity from Issa’s committee before he would give any more paperwork to them.  Having failed to get the desired immunity, Holder asked President Obama to lock up the requested documents.

One significant Senator blasted the use of executive privilege: “There’s been a tendency on the part of this administration to try to hide behind executive privilege every time there’s something a little shaky taking place.  The administration would be best served by coming clean on this.”

Ironically, that quote does not come from any Republican in the Senate, but rather from then-Sen. Barack Obama during a CNN interview on March 19, 2007.

The President has just raised the stakes as his actions today point to his involvement in either planning or covering up the fallout related to Operation Fast & Furious.

REMEMBER:  Those who are close to this investigation have concluded that Operation Fast & Furious was nothing more than attempt to bring new and stronger gun control laws which would only render Americans less safe.

But the Operation blew up in their faces after hundreds of people were killed by Fast & Furious guns — and in particular, a Border Patrol named Brian Terry in December, 2010.

ACTION: Now that Issa’s committee has voted to hold the Attorney General in contempt, it means that the full House will have to vote on the citation.  So please take the following action:


1. Click here to contact your Representative and urge him to VOTE IN FAVOR OF holding the Attorney General in contempt.

2. If your Representative is a member of the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee and voted in favor of the contempt citation today, thank him.  If he opposed it, then blast him!